
The National Grain and Feed Association filed comments with the Surface Transportation Board opposing the proposed merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, arguing that eliminating a major railroad would reduce competition and harm agricultural shippers' access to reliable, cost-effective rail transportation.
- NGFA contends the merger would eliminate a major Class I railroad and significantly reduce competition in an already concentrated freight rail industry
- Agricultural shippers depend on competitive rail options to move grain, feed, and other products to domestic and international markets
- NGFA is urging the STB to focus on regulatory reforms including rate reasonableness, service reliability improvements, and removing barriers to rail competition
- If the board considers approval, NGFA outlined fallback protections needed: preserving competitive options, protecting against service deterioration, and establishing accountability for post-merger disruptions
- The Agricultural Transportation Working Group filed separate comments supporting NGFA's position on rail-on-rail competition and service risks
The National Grain and Feed Association has filed additional comments with the Surface Transportation Board urging the agency to deny the revised application to merge Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern.
NGFA said in a Wednesday announcement that the transaction would harm rail competition and service reliability for agricultural shippers and is not consistent with the public interest.
The argument is direct. The merger would eliminate a major Class I railroad, and NGFA contends that the resulting loss of competition would create significant risks for grain, feed and other agricultural shippers. Those harms, the association said, would far outweigh the limited benefits of the expanded single-line rail service cited by the applicants.
"The proposed merger would further consolidate an already highly concentrated freight rail industry, with potentially serious consequences for the agricultural supply chain," said Mike Seyfert, NGFA president and CEO. "Our members depend on competitive, reliable and cost-effective rail transportation to move agricultural products to domestic and international markets."
Seyfert said the association does not believe the transaction meets the public-interest standard required for approval.
NGFA is not only asking for a denial. It urged the board to put its attention on regulatory changes addressing long-standing problems for rail shippers, including rate reasonableness, service reliability, unreasonable tariff provisions and surcharges, and barriers to rail competition.
The filing also sets out a fallback position. While NGFA maintains that no conditions could fully offset the loss of competition, it outlined long-term protections it said would be necessary if the board considers approval. Those include preserving and expanding competitive rail options, protecting shippers against service deterioration and establishing accountability for post-merger service disruptions.
"Rather than allowing further consolidation, we encourage the STB to focus on policies that strengthen competition, improve rail service and make the freight rail system more responsive to the needs of agricultural shippers," Seyfert said.
Other farm groups made a similar case through the Agricultural Transportation Working Group. In a separate filing cited by NGFA, the group said the merger "would cause harm to rail-on-rail competition and create more rail service risk for agricultural shippers."
The railroads have argued that the combination would expand single-line service, according to NGFA's description of the application. The association's announcement did not include the filing itself, the specific conditions it requested or the board's schedule for a decision.














