close [X]

Apr 21, 2021

Update: 2020 Iowa Derecho Damage

What was the contribution of 2020 Iowa derecho damage to the U.S. corn yield?

On January 12, 2021, the USDA released its 2020 end-of-season national corn yield estimate of 172.0 bushel/acre, lowering the stocks-to-use ratio and supporting continued bullish sentiment in grain trading markets. What was the contribution of 2020 Iowa derecho damage to the US corn yield?

The CropProphet 2020 technology trend estimate for corn is 178.3 bushel/acre. Therefore, the USDA national corn yield estimate was 6.3 bushel/acre below the technology trend, which is the second-largest deviation from trend since the drought year of 2012.

The USDA February 2021 release of final estimate county-level corn yield data allows us to examine the most significant weather impacts on the 2020 crop: the August 10, 2020, Iowa derecho.

The county-level corn yield deviation from the technology trend is shown below and indicates substantial yield shortfalls for many counties in Iowa and northern Illinois.

2020 corn dev trend

Iowa Derecho: August 10, 2020

The derecho swept through Iowa and northern Illinois from west to east during the day on August 10, 2020. Many counties experienced wind speeds of at least 60 mph, but wind speeds in some isolated areas are estimated to have exceeded 120 mph. Using data provided by the National Weather Service, the graphic below depicts the range of peak wind speeds affecting counties across the Midwest.

NWS Derecho analysis 2

Shortly after the Iowa derecho event, CropProphet estimated the likely impact of the derecho on US corn production.

With US county yield and production data for 2020 now available, we can better estimate the Iowa derecho damage caused to national corn yield.

2020 Iowa Derecho Impact on Corn Yield

The regions of high wind speed shown above allow us to more explicitly calculate the derecho’s impact on national corn yields. The graphic below overlays the derecho wind speed estimate from the NWS with the county deviation from trend.

It is quite evident that counties in central Iowa with the most significant deviation from technology trends closely align with the regions that experienced greater than 80 mph wind speeds. A few counties reported corn yield deviations below -80 bu/ac.

Derecho 3

Iowa Derecho Damage Estimate

This data enables grouping counties by wind speed to measure the impact of the derecho in Iowa and Illinois.

Cornyieldimpact 4

The 60-70 mph wind speed category encompasses all counties impacted by the derecho and represents the derecho’s overall corn yield impact in each state. All counties inside the 60-70 mph contour experienced an average corn yield decline relative to the technology trend of -31.1 bu/ac in Iowa and -11.5 bu/ac in Illinois.

This estimate assumes the yield in both states would have been equal to the technology trend had there been no derecho. A bad assumption. For example, Iowa counties not impacted by the derecho averaged almost -13 bu/ac below the technology trend. Iowa experienced a regional but fairly intense drought throughout the season, contributing to lower corn yields in the state.

July 2020 was drier than normal for Iowa and August 2020 was drier than normal for both Iowa and Illinois. These drought-like conditions undoubtedly also negatively impacted corn yield.

July Aug2020 5

To address this, the “No Impact” category in the above table provides the deviation from trend values averaged over counties impacted by the derecho in each state. This can be considered the baseline yield estimate by which to compare the impact of the derecho. It is calculated using neighboring counties in their respective state to the derecho impacted counties.

Derecho Impact on National Corn Yield

The next step estimates the derecho’s impact on the national corn yield. Just as the table above shows the corn yield impact in derecho impacted counties, we calculate the deviation from technology trend in counties with no derecho damage, shown below.

National cornimpact 6

The table also shows the harvested acres percent to total national acres for Iowa and Illinois counties both impacted and non-impacted by the derecho. In Iowa derecho impacted counties contribute an average of 7.4% of the US total corn acres. Likewise, the Illinois derecho-effected counties contribute 8.1% of national corn production.

The impact of the August 2020 derecho on national yield is -2.3 bu/ac for Iowa and -0.9 bu/ac for Illinois. The total derecho damage on US national corn yield is therefore -3.2 bu/ac without consideration of other factors.

We have to consider what the “baseline” corn yield would have been without a derecho. As discussed above, this is calculated using the yield deviation from neighboring counties and allows us to adjust the estimate of the derecho’s direct impact on national yield. To do this we subtract the harvested acres weighted “non-impacted” counties average technology trend from the previous estimate.
So,

The Iowa derecho impact is -2.3 – (-0.5) = -1.7 bu/ac.

The Illinois derecho impact is -0.9 – 0.0 = -0.9 bu/ac.

The derecho’s impact on the national corn yield is -1.7 + -0.9 or -2.6 bu/ac. The damage caused by the 2020 Iowa derecho is less than half of the -6.3 bu/ac U.S. corn national deviation from trend.

Derecho Impact on Production

Using the same information, we can estimate the impact of the derecho on production. We can’t however, estimate a baseline production estimate. This method, therefore, overestimates the impact on corn production.

The production impact is estimated by measuring the 2020 final county production values from the production technology trend for each county. The 60-70 mph category is the largest area and encompasses all affected counties. The estimate of the damage caused by the Iowa derecho on national production was that it was reduced by approximately 372 M bushel.

Cornimpact 7

Recall that in our September 2020 post estimating the Iowa derecho damage we state “If this estimate is correct, it implies a production loss of about 175-350 million bushels (Mb) in Iowa alone.” As stated above, this production damage estimate is likely high because we calculate relative to the production technology trend. Our initial estimate ended up accurate.

For more information on CropProphet, click here.

Author
Dr. Jan F. Dutton, Ph.D., MBA is the CEO of Prescient Weather Ltd and ClimBiz Ltd. His career spans positions at Weather Ventures, Earth Networks, Storm Exchange, Schneider Electric, and DTN. Dr. Dutton’s career objective is to enable business decision making based on weather and climate information.

He received a dual degree B.A. in Physics and Science and Technology Studies from Colby College in Waterville, ME in 1994. He received a Ph.D. from the Penn State Department of Meteorology in 2000. He also received an MBA from the Smeal College Business at Penn State in 2000. His dissertation focused on the simulation of interannual climate variability using regional climate models. Dr. Dutton is honored to strengthen existing and build new customer and partner relationships based on the unique leading-edge climate analysis and forecasting capabilities created by Prescient Weather Ltd.


Recently Added to Buyer's Guide

Ultra Scoop

  • 20,000 bushels/hour
  • 40-foot inclined conveyor

TruGro Weight Management for Pets

  • Plant-based ingredient solution for pet food, treats, and supplements
  • Standardized, polyphenol-rich botanical extracts containing compounds naturally occurring in green tea leaves

Access Platforms

  • Anti-slip access platforms to reach elevated process equipment safely
  • Modular system includes braced frames which can be bolted to floor

HP FiberBoost©

  • Contains functional fibers produced specifically for dietetic use in piglets
  • Fiber stimulates gut and eases transition at weaning

Huve Check-Feed

  • On-site screening test to detect monensin, including Monovet® 90, in feedstuffs
  • Produces accurate, reliable results without adding microtracer particles to feed for detection methods

VM-13.3 G

  • Industrial-grade 13.3-inch LCD monitor
  • Full HD resolution: 1920 x 1080 (1080p/60)

Magazine

Marketwatch: Dec, 04

cmdty National Corn Price Idx: ZCPAUS.CM

open: 5.6684
high: 5.7321
low: 5.6559
close: 5.7046

cmdty National Soybean Price Idx: ZSPAUS.CM

open: 12.266
high: 12.366
low: 12.2585
close: 12.34

cmdty National Hard Red Winter Wheat Price Idx: KEPAUS.CM

open: 8.1277
high: 8.243
low: 7.9921
close: 8.0144

cmdty National Soft Red Winter Wheat Price Idx: ZWPAUS.CM

open: 7.6225
high: 7.7249
low: 7.4749
close: 7.5391