
A study by the American Great Lakes Ports Association found that shipping grain from Port Milwaukee to the Gulf of Mexico by water could save approximately $4.50 per ton in linehaul costs compared to rail, with potential annual savings ranging from $112,000 to $447,000 depending on cargo volume.
- Water shipping grain costs $26.70 to $36.20 per ton versus $30.50 to $41.30 by rail
- The all-water route spans 1,472 miles compared to 982 miles by rail, but lower barge costs offset the distance
- Diverting 100,000 tons annually would remove approximately 1,000 rail cars from the network
- Key barriers include the BNSF rail bridge at Lemont, Illinois and 10 locks on the route to the Gulf
- The study identified 15 recommendations across market development, industry priorities, policy coordination, and infrastructure improvements
Shipping grain from Port Milwaukee to the Gulf of Mexico by lake and barge instead of rail could save about $4.50 per ton in linehaul costs and add a route around low water on the Upper Mississippi River, according to a study released Tuesday by the American Great Lakes Ports Association.
The Great Freight Connection, conducted by CPCS Transcom Inc., examines why so little freight moves between the Great Lakes and the inland waterway system and where cross-system cargo could make economic sense. The Great Lakes St. Lawrence Seaway Development Corporation, Ports of Indiana, the Illinois International Port District and Port Milwaukee funded the work.
The two systems moved more than 138 million tons of cargo in 2023, but less than 1% of outbound Great Lakes tonnage, about 558,000 tons, moved onto the Illinois Waterway, and about 5% of outbound Illinois Waterway tonnage went to the Great Lakes. The Illinois Waterway, which sent 65% of its outbound tonnage to the Lower Mississippi, is "fundamentally an export corridor," particularly for agricultural goods, the study said.
"We know there are opportunities to move more cargo between the Great Lakes and inland waterways, and this study helps us see where the economics make sense," said Erik Varela, executive director of the Illinois International Port District and vice president of the ports association.
Grain lane pencils out on paper
The study modeled four illustrative trade lanes at 25,000, 50,000 and 100,000 tons a year and said the results are order-of-magnitude estimates, not investment-grade forecasts. The grain and bulk agricultural lane would move product southbound from export terminals at Port Milwaukee, where silos have been expanded at the agricultural terminal, to Gulf facilities for distribution or export.
The all-water route runs 1,472 miles, compared with 982 miles by rail, but lower barge costs per ton-mile largely offset the distance, and the lake segment adds only 127 miles. The study estimated costs of $26.70 to $36.20 per ton by water, compared with $30.50 to $41.30 by rail. Annual linehaul savings were estimated at $112,000 at 25,000 tons, $224,000 at 50,000 tons and $447,000 at 100,000 tons, with a range of $380,000 to $514,000 at the highest volume. Diverting 100,000 tons would take about 1,000 rail cars off the network.
The study cautioned that rail is already cost-efficient for bulk grain and that the comparison does not fully count loading, unloading, storage and handling costs. Competitiveness will depend on seasonality, equipment availability, volume commitments and congestion in the Chicago rail hub, a bottleneck stakeholders consistently identified. Per-ton carbon dioxide emissions for the water route ran about 4.8% higher than rail because of the added distance.
"For Port Milwaukee, this is about building on the connections we already have and finding new ways to serve the businesses that rely on them," said Benjamin Timm, Port Milwaukee port director.
The other modeled lanes covered steel from Burns Harbor, Indiana, to Peoria, Illinois, and St. Louis, liquid bulk from Joliet, Illinois, to Milwaukee and salt from the Gulf to the Port of Chicago.
Barriers between the systems
The study identified the BNSF rail bridge over the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal at Lemont, Illinois, as the biggest physical disconnect between the systems. The T.J. O'Brien Lock is the only navigable connection, and cargo bound for the Gulf passes through 10 locks, eight of them on the Illinois Waterway. The closure of the Lockport lock from January to June 2025 pushed shippers to truck and rail.
Regulatory and equipment limits also weigh on the corridor. U.S. Coast Guard policies generally limit movements between the Chicago, Burns Harbor and Milwaukee ports to three-barge tows, and the Coast Guard requires barges calling at Port Milwaukee to be 10 years old or newer, while the inland barge fleet averaged about 21 years old in 2023. Winter closures shut Great Lakes navigation for two to three months a year.
The study made 15 recommendations in four areas: market development and partnerships, priority industries and commodities, policy and regulatory coordination and strategic infrastructure improvements. They include targeted outreach to agricultural associations.
"The Great Lakes and inland waterways are vital to moving the agricultural products, raw materials, and manufactured goods that power our economy," said Mike McCoshen, administrator of the seaway corporation.
.jpg?auto=format%2Ccompress&crop=faces&fit=crop&h=48&q=70&w=48)















